Philosophical Question #5 – Strangers vs. Loved Ones

  • Would you kill ten people to save one?

Yes, we all know of the trolley car conundrum and throwing the switch to “save the many, vs the one.”  I think many here, actually many universally, probably see that resolution the same way, regarding these hypothetical strangers.  We’d do it, save the many instead of the one.

But let’s complicate/rethink Spock's dilemma of the "needs of the many outweighing the needs of the few, or the one."  What if that ONE needing saved was a loved one?  Would you still kill the ONE (e.g., your spouse/significant other, child, mom, dad, etc.) to save ten strangers?  Does the situation/calculation change now for you??  Does love overpower reason?  Explain.

(by PrimalSoup)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The MonoRacer 130E Fully Enclosed Motorcycle Aims to Redefine Personal Mobility

Image
The MonoRacer 130E Fully Enclosed Motorcycle Aims to Redefine Personal Mobility Elena Gorgan The idea of making something that would be halfway between a bicycle or motorcycle and a car is not new; after all, the advantages of such a vehicle would be many for a large segment of the market. In the Czech Republic, inventor, fabricator and full-time pilot Arnold Wagner has been making one such vehicle since the late ‘80s. Since 2009, with a new partner, he launched the  PERAVES CZ  company, and they’ve been putting out these cabin-motorcycles dubbed MonoRacer since then. They probably haven’t sold more than a couple of hundred of them (90 of which were made before the 2009 partnership), but that could change as early as this month. As it turns out, PERAVES CZ has made an electric version of the MonoRacer, called the MonoRacer 130E, and it is now in the process of receiving EU-certification. The MonoRacer 130E is an electric motorcycle with a fully enclosed cabi...
Read more

Invite list - authors on here please take note.

@Stardust4U:disqus @ellabulldog:disqus @disqus_acdYWH93ek:disqus @jamie_bobini:disqus @KidChaos_74656:disqus @JPBunny:disqus  @SvdH:disqus @suzieseller:disqus @disqus_rFxGwbDGog:disqus  @KipSmithers:disqus   @dntkch:disqus  @Cats_Paw:disqus @disqus_vDsBtBJWlh:disqus @homebuilding23:disqus @brmckay:disqus @Thundersrealm:disqus @jnfrcrpic:disqus  @disqus_fAOjGxR18w:disqus  @WolfieOne:disqus  @disqus_6cAA5VxMRr:disqus @e_monster:disqus @Avantiman:disqus   @jaegirl:disqus  @disqus_cVSBvWF8Zb:disqus @disqus_1Jjgee5bqr:disqus @guymendez:disqus @Alexthekay:disqus @strontidog:disqus @larrymotuz:disqus  @disqus_fR0TSz3rla:disqus  @disqus_8lLmVOvJaT:disqus  @pwod:disqus  @disqus_mkwzdumS7o:disqus @FunGussy:disqus  @imperatormachinarum:disqus @lantanalane:disqus  @unclepatrick:disqus @cmogruder:disqus 
Read more

Confronting Bluster 😡💢🗯🗯

Image
  So, what is bluster? By definition: - to speak or act in a noisy, angry, or threatening way without saying anything important As good enough an explanation as any I guess, but it really doesn't say it all. Back when I was a kid, there was always that kid on the teams that would lose at whatever game it was and get mad while blaming someone else for the loss, even though they'd been a major part in the loss. So I naively assumed that bluster was only a sore loser thing. As I got older and worked I found out that it was also a tactic to try and scare others from fighting back. So a poker reference here, it's very similar to someone going "all in" right away to discourage anyone from calling the bet. Now, we see it quite often in politics, usually with doubling down if it's confronted. In politics as a tactic, it's meant to scare the politician's opponents, but also to distract from the other things the politician has failed to deliver and/or actually w...
Read more